13 Comments
User's avatar
Nicolas Krause's avatar

I was surprised that you didn’t mention the YouTube channel Clickspring https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZioPDnFPNsHnyxfygxA0to4RXv4_jDU2&si=LzPex_vlbdGHHiXW

He’s a talented machinist building a replica that also has resulted in a published paper.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27937251

Handle's avatar

I would like to second the recommendation for Clickspring (Chris Budiselic). He has a working model made with tools and techniques consistent with those that would have been available at the time period and that works smoothly and accurately with regard to lunar phase, lunar cycle, eclipse prediction, and most of the best scholarship published on the device.

Brendan Foley's avatar

I co-directed excavations on the Antikythera Wreck site 2012-2017. I am certain the Mechanism was aboard the ship that sank there in the first century BCE. I recovered a copper alloy artifact that might have been part of it, published in a news article in Nature in 2016. The Mechanism isn't dated by the coins from the wreck; those only provide a terminus ante quem.

I am certain there is only one wreck at that specific location. I have also dived on the ancient wreck that is about 300 m south on the same coast, and recovered artifacts from it to compare to the Antikythera Wreck. It's probably contemporary, but for internal politicsl reasons, the Greek authorities obstructed analyses.

Chandhana's avatar

do you disagree with ESAG’s dive report that claims is a second ship? https://www.esag.swiss/antikythera2024/

Brendan Foley's avatar

Please see my previous comment, where I noted the existence of the othet ancient wreck that is ~300 m south of the Antikythera Wreck.

Chandhana's avatar

do you have photos from your dive? it would be useful to make your account public. without your direct account, i do not believe there are any other primary sources that suggest a contemporary origin of the ship (yet)

Chandhana's avatar

ah i misunderstood your wording, appreciate the clarification

Handle's avatar

Incredible writeup. I am looking forward to the CAD model and eventual construction of a working recreation

Fahad Hasin's avatar

Superb and so original.

Sebastian Garren's avatar

I'm scratching my head thinking about whether there is anything in Ptolemy that would allow us to date the AM as before him for sure. But the Saros cycle of the moon in Hipparchus and Ptolemy is only different over very long periods - not something I'd expecting the AM to pick up.

Hipparchus was just too good.

The device must predate Maftianus Capella because by the 5th century astronomical knowledge is clearly slipping. But it also seems to post-date the knowledge base of Pliny the Elder 1st century (though that is not evidence per se), since Pliny is worse than Hipparchus on several points despite being born well after him.

I've always assumed the device was an Alexandrian Ptolemaic fan club victory lap. "Look at these sweet tables: we just need to apply mean motion gears!" Then you can use it for demonstrations and teaching the inner circle.

Deborah's avatar

Very impressive work, Chandhana! You never cease to amaze me.

Alex Chan's avatar

This is so fascinating, thanks for sharing! Makes me wonder what other technologies haven’t been found that were ahead of its time like this