Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Confessions on Modern Philanthropy with: Suhag Shukla (Hindu American Foundation)

A conversation about the “boxed salad” version of spirituality, building an advocacy organization, and fundraising for diffuse progress.

Welcome to the confession booth.

Suhag Shukla co-founded the Hindu American Foundation (HAF) over a kitchen table 23 years ago and is now its Executive Director. She trained as a lawyer, and for years people in her own community asked what her “real job” was. Hindu American institutions were mostly volunteer-run, and paying staff to do advocacy and education work was new.

In this episode, we explore the multiplicity within Hinduism and ask her what it takes to raise funds when grant-makers see the word “Hindu” and assume it’s an ineligible religious organization.


We talk about:

Suhag’s story

  • Starting HAF: a second generation building on the first [0:46]

  • Growing up Hindu in 1970s California, and learning to ask why [5:58]

Many ways of being Hindu

  • There is no one way to be Hindu [13:57]

Appreciation and appropriation

  • What a guru is for: “concierge spirituality” [21:43]

  • The salad analogy: when the boxed version is a good entry point [23:35]

  • HAF’s Take Back Yoga campaign [25:11]

Old ideas, new words

  • Flow states and the Gita [30:01]

  • Even in temples, we are still human [34:37]

  • Dharma, Artha, Kama, Moksha as four natural human aspirations [36:18]

Fundraising for the intangible

  • Why education and advocacy are hard to pitch to donors [38:44]

  • A 60-slide deck, a first $10,000 check, and the first hire [40:57]

  • “Philanthropy doesn’t work that way”: relationships over mass small gifts [43:20]

Estates, endowments, and the future of giving

  • Estate giving and a one-year runway [45:32]

  • Giving as duty, and why success breeds complacency [47:40]

  • What Suhag thinks Hindu thought offers on shared problems [50:18]


Our favorite lines from this episode include:

On diffuse progress:

“Education and advocacy are intangible in some sense, at least in terms of the wins. They are not instant gratification. They are not short term. … How do you measure that?”

On estate giving:

“It’s a lot easier to give $1 million, $2 million, whatever it is, once you are confident you don’t need it because you’re not here anymore.”

On commercialized yoga and meditation:

“I use the analogy of a salad, okay? … There’s a spectrum of where we are in our spiritual growth. If using that boxed salad is your entry point to eventually getting to better, higher quality ingredients, I think it serves a purpose. But again, if you’re running off with these things without acknowledging the roots of it, I think it doesn’t serve your constituency well.”


About Suhag: Suhag Shukla is the Executive Director and a co-founder of the Hindu American Foundation. She holds a BA in Religion and a JD from the University of Florida. She has served on the boards of the National Museum of American Religion and YWCA Minneapolis, and as a faith adviser to the Council on Foreign Relations and the Humane Society of the United States. In 2017 the Center for American Progress named her one of twelve faith leaders to watch, and in 2023 the US Department of Health and Human Services recognized her among 15 women faith leaders.


If you want to go deeper, here are the references from this episode:

Thanks for reading Analogue Press!

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?